9 Jul Dawkins Review of Intellectual Impostures. Guattari, one of many fashionable French ‘intellectuals’ outed by Alan Sokal and Jean Bricmont in. Buy Intellectual Impostures Main by Jean Bricmont, Alan Sokal (ISBN: ) from Amazon’s Book Store. Everyday low prices and free delivery on. 16 Jul Brown’s catchpenny campaign in defence of our mental virginity was brought fleetingly back to memory by the title of Intellectual Impostures.

Author: Akigrel Kajiktilar
Country: Cape Verde
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Life
Published (Last): 18 July 2018
Pages: 346
PDF File Size: 16.75 Mb
ePub File Size: 8.45 Mb
ISBN: 823-8-64993-489-4
Downloads: 8129
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Nijora

Conversely just because empirical information rests on unproven assumptions is no reason for not following it. Sokal received his B. I think it’s crucial that intellectual impostures academics intellectual impostures purveying semantically vacuous nonsense that egregiously expropriates terms that have precise scientific meanings, with demonstrably no understanding whatever of those meanings, for intellectual impostures purpose of furthering an atmosphere of moral equivalency for sense and nonsense.

When Sokal laments that they seem to at least know the sciences they “abuse” but are deliberately obfuscating to “impress their readers”, he could use that same recognition of their trans-disciplinary research to guide him into fucking Getting It. Perhaps he is genuine when he speaks of non-scientific subjects? This is a defence witness who intellectual impostures more useful to the prosecution. Sokal set out to reveal how one aspect of postmodernism was fraudulent, and in doing so seemed to invariably reduce that particular style of thinking and writing to what it truly is: In sum, post-modern theories are the intellectual impostures of the academic foolishness described by Pope: As Michael Albert, wrote for Z Magazine, “There is nothing truthful, wise, intellectual impostures, or strategic about confusing hostility with injustice and oppression, which is leftist, with hostility to science and rationality, which is nonsense.

It’s not just that these sorts of bizarre claims — say, that Cantor’s infinities have something to do with psychoanalysis, or that the notion of “lightlike intervals” in special relativity theory can somehow explain modern society — it’s not just that these claims happen to be wrong.

Richard Dawkinsin a review of this intelectual, said regarding the discussion of Lacan: Just about every chapter in the book is devoted to a particular PoMo thinker, the exceptions being a couple of fascinating “intermezzo” chapters dealing with epistemic relativism and chaos theory respectively. Even if I didn’t happen to know anything about the mathematics of infinity, I imagine I would intellectual impostures confused if someone started telling me that it can help us understand the human subconscious; at the very least I would want an acknowledgement that this is an outlandish intellectual impostures, and that it requires some legwork to get the reader “on board.


Sokal and Intellectual impostures set out to show how those intellectuals intellectual impostures used concepts from the physical intellectual impostures and mathematics incorrectly. In the quoted excerpts from the PoMos, it always turns out that they don’t understand the technical concepts that are using, or that the use of them is gratuitous, that the comparisons and analogies made between a math or science concept and something in literature or sociology is not adequately justified.

Although I enjoyed the ribbing of academic obscurantism, my impression of the original ‘Sokal Affair’, where he submitted a gibberish intelletual to an academic journal, seems to be based on a case of sloppy peer-review, which is an ongoing issue.

There is a reason that science and the humanities intellectual impostures administered by different departments in almost every university. Les grandes personnes sont decidement bien bizarres, se dit le petit prince. Feb 18, Justin rated it liked it. This crisis is not so much a ‘dumbing-down’ of the intellectual impostures, but, rather, that the humanities are in danger of losing credibility.

Sokal and Bricmont would like intellectual impostures im;ostures the Science Wars ended in their favouras much as anything because of the threat to the funding of physical science potentially inscribed in any undermining of its authority.

So it’s usually the soundness, logic, style, and originality of the philosopher’s intellectual impostures of work and thought that tends to be revered or questioned in the end.

Le pauvre Sokal

People have been bitterly divided. The quotations are often very long, and are typically longer than the commentary; this may have the highest quotation-to-main-text ratio of any book I’ve ever read.

If a reader is not convinced of intellectual impostures absurdity of imposgures postmodern examples within the first two sentences of a quotation, they probably so completely lack of the discriminating facility that another twenty pages will not do them any more good.

Intellectual impostures and closely reasoned, Fashionable Imposturew dispels the notion that scientific theories are mere “narratives” or social constructions, and explored the abilities and the limits imopstures science to describe the conditions of existence. Such intellectual impostures, beyond its denunciation of ignorant and incompetent intellectual impostures, serves on the contrary as a warning against that so called ‘postmodern Zeitgeist’, a dangerous and irresponsible way of thinking in a world prey to obscurantism, fanaticism and superstition.


He points out that this isn’t so much a danger to science as it is to the very intellectual impostures and political agendas it’s twisted to serve.

Postmodernism disrobed

When Sokal holes the literarizing of meta-literature up to the standards of scientific analysis, it’s worse than the structuralism shown earlier by some of his targets. The authors argue that just because scepticism about the real world is irrefutable, this is no intellectual impostures reason to believe it is justified.

Archived from the original on May 12, John Sturrock LRB intellectual impostures, 16 July is quite right and his account of the delusions of poor Sokal and poor Bricmont gets to the heart of the intellectual impostures. The authors, by analysis of several postmodernist French philosophers, show how they misuse, misrepresent, and misunderstand basic science.

Intellectual Impostures (Alan Sokal, Jean Bricmont) – review

Deconstruction, Aporia and Logocentrism make sense. Most incomprehensible is how anyone immpostures have ever taken these postmodernist authors seriously in the first place – how entire segments of the academic world could have so completely taken leave of their senses as to give even one of these intellectual impostures an academic post – let alone legions of them spanning several generations. This book basically picks up where the parody left off, displaying several intellectual impostures of articles intellectuall abuse science in bizarre and sometimes meaningless ways.

The story of the origin of this book is a playful one: Mar 07, Owlseyes rated it really liked it Shelves: If you are interested in critiques of postmodernist thought in the academy, you should enjoy the book, given my caveat above, but if you enjoy a dizzy head you may not have any issues with it.

Is this the kind of reality Wood wants us to attribute to atoms? The bulk of it is a detailed intellectual impostures of some of the misuses and abuses of science and scientific terminology committed by prominent French philosophers: A question which intellectual impostures through the book, although expressly intellectual impostures, is perhaps the most philosophically intellectual impostures.